My Sugar Pie is a gourmet homemade pie brand that offers an array of delectable pies. Founded by Kelly, who has a background in education and a passion for baking, My Sugar Pie is a dream turned reality. Kelly's expertise in pie baking was passed down from her mom, Marge McLain, who serves as a constant source of inspiration and support.

With years of experience baking pies for loved ones, Kelly's dedication and love for her craft shines through in each and every pie she creates. At My Sugar Pie, you'll find a wide selection of mouthwatering pies to satisfy any craving. From classic flavors like apple and cherry to unique creations like key lime and chocolate peanut butter, there's something for everyone.

Whether you're looking for a sweet treat to enjoy at home or need pies for an event or catering, My Sugar Pie has you covered. Visit their Zionsville shop and indulge in their Summer Slice Special, where you can buy two slices and get one free. Experience the deliciousness of My Sugar Pie and treat yourself to a slice of homemade perfection